🤔 If I Were Mayor: How I’d Actually Transform a City’s Transport System (Part 1)


November 19th, 2026

​Subscribe​

If I Were Mayor: How I’d Actually Transform a City’s Transport System (Part 1)

Key Takeaways

  • Many transport strategies already call for less car dominance; the real problem is that they rarely get delivered.
  • The gap between strategy and implementation is a political problem, not a technical one.
  • “Liveability” is a powerful political message because it means different things to different people and works across the political spectrum.
  • That same flexibility can make liveability hard to turn into clear policy, and cities often end up staying car-dependent.
  • Commuters stuck in traffic usually want road upgrades, and when public opinion and expert advice disagree, the public almost always wins.
  • Anne Hidalgo’s approach in Paris benefited from advantages most city leaders lack, including an inner-city electorate and major Metro investment.
  • A war on cars is a losing political strategy.
  • Instead, politicians should side with frustrated drivers and promise better alternatives, so that fewer people need to drive and those who do face less competition for road space and parking.
  • This is a harder message than “more roads and more parking,” but a good communicator can sell it and show results within one four-year term.
  • Twelve policy levers, delivered in a way that builds political support, can transform a city and win re-election.

What Next?

Have you seen one of these policies done well, or badly, in your city? Real examples will help shape the coming posts.

Introduction

Over the past couple of months, I’ve written a series of articles looking at our transport systems from different perspectives. I haven’t covered every angle yet, but one direction of travel keeps coming up: we need to rebalance our transport systems away from motor vehicles and towards walking, cycling and public transport.

Long-time readers won’t be surprised by that position. Many transport strategies already say much the same thing. The problem is what happens next. A new strategy is published, decision makers don’t make the changes it calls for, and the car-dominated status quo continues.

So how do we get past this impasse?

To explore it, I’m going to run through a series of thought experiments. Over the coming weeks, I’ll imagine I’m the Mayor of a whole city. I’ll set out the political narrative I would use and how I would deliver each policy in a way that is politically successful, not just technically sound.

This first article covers the overall narrative and introduces the policies I’d pursue.

The Right Political Narrative

A few weeks ago, I wrote about how the former Mayor of Paris, Anne Hidalgo, made the case for shifting away from motor vehicles towards walking, cycling and public transport. She didn’t base it on the environment. She based it on health and on making Paris a more liveable city.

“Liveable” is a fairly vague term, and in politics that’s exactly what makes it useful. It means different things to different people, and almost everyone wants a more liveable life. It creates good vibes.

It also works across the political spectrum. Centre-left and centre-right politicians can both campaign on liveability; they just emphasise different things. Hidalgo, a centre-left politician, focused on cleaner air, safer streets and more space for people. A centre-right politician might focus on a strong local economy, thriving high streets and less time wasted in traffic. The banner is the same, but the emphasis is different.

That flexibility is liveability’s greatest strength as a political message. As we’ll see, it’s also a significant weakness when it comes to delivery.

From Liveability To Policy

The real challenge comes when we try to turn liveability’s good vibes into actual policies. If liveable means different things to different people, it can quickly become all things to all people. Frankly, many transport systems have suffered from exactly this. Cities that invest in both public transport and roads end up car-dependent anyway, because driving stays the default option for most people.

It’s not hard to see why. Put yourself in the shoes of someone living in a car-dependent suburb, commuting for around an hour each way, much of it stuck in traffic. For them, a more liveable city means an end to their daily traffic nightmare, and the obvious fix is to upgrade the roads.

We know this (usually) doesn’t work. But for politicians trying to win votes, when public opinion and expert advice disagree, the public will (almost) always win. This is where most cities are stuck. They may have a transport strategy that’s sound on paper, but will it actually be delivered? More often than not, the answer is no.

One option is to do what Hidalgo did and define liveability in a pro-cycling, pro-public-space way. But Hidalgo had political advantages that most city leaders don’t. She governed only inner Paris, with around 2 million residents, while the wider Île-de-France region has more than 12 million. Most of the 10 million people outside her electorate live in the more car-dependent suburbs. Paris has also benefited from major investment and extensions of its Metro, improving alternatives to the car.

Most city politicians don’t have those advantages, whatever liveability message got them elected.

What I Would Do

If I were responsible for a city and had to turn liveability into a set of commitments, this is what I would do.

First, I would side with the people who spend hours in traffic every week and have to fight for a parking space. Their travel experience is miserable, created by a poor transport and land-use system, and elected politicians are right to try to improve it. I would distance myself from anyone calling for a war on cars. Politically, it’s a losing strategy.

The second part of my plan is where I would differ from most politicians. I wouldn’t make the usual popular promises that don’t work, such as more roads, more free parking, and free or very cheap public transport. Instead, my message would be that I’m going to improve the alternatives so that more people choose not to drive. That directly benefits the people who still drive, because they face less competition for road space and for parking.

This is a harder message than the easy but wrong one. But I’ve been lucky enough to work for, and alongside, some outstanding political communicators, and I’m confident a good communicator can explain it to the public. It doesn’t take a great one. More importantly, with the right policies implemented in the right way (and this is critical), it’s a message that can be backed by visible results within a single four-year term.

So what are those policies?

The Key Policy Levers

Here are the twelve policy levers I would pull:

  1. Safe routes to school: more children walking and cycling to school
  2. Parking reform: better management of parking supply and demand
  3. Walkable neighbourhoods: making the city easier and more pleasant to walk around
  4. A segregated cycle network: comprehensive and connected, not piecemeal
  5. Better public transport: more frequent, more reliable and easier to use
  6. Car-free access to high streets: making local centres easy to reach and navigate without a car
  7. Transformed public squares: reclaiming space for people
  8. Car-free days on steroids: regular, ambitious and city-wide
  9. Integrated transport and land use: building homes and jobs where good transport already is
  10. Road user charging: pricing road space fairly
  11. Low traffic neighbourhoods: quieter, safer residential streets
  12. Supercharged car share: making it more viable to give up car ownership

Over the coming weeks, I’ll look at each of these in turn. I’ll set out exactly what I would do, how I would make each policy politically viable, and a vote winner in its own right, based on what has worked elsewhere.

What I wouldn’t do is implement them in the traditional top-down way. That approach so often triggers a political backlash, and has put other politicians off attempting these reforms at all.

Would these policies transform a city's transport system and win re-election? I believe so. Some of them will face fierce opposition. But implemented in the right way and backed by the right arguments, I believe most of the public will support them, and the politicians who deliver them will be re-elected.

Next week, I’ll start with getting more children walking and cycling to school.

Conclusion

Most cities don’t need a new transport strategy. They need a way to deliver the one they already have. The gap between strategy and implementation is a political problem, and it needs a political answer.

The answer I’m proposing starts by siding with the people who are the victims of how we travel today, including those stuck in traffic and circling for a parking space, rather than fighting them. Instead of easy promises that don’t work, it offers a different deal: better alternatives, so more people choose not to drive while maintaining the political support of those who still need or want to drive.

That deal only works if the policies behind it are delivered in the right way. Over the coming weeks, I’ll go through each of the twelve policy levers and look at how to make them visible, popular and defensible within a single four-year term. Liveability may be a fuzzy idea, but if it’s turned into the right commitments and delivered well, it can change our cities and win elections for the centre left and the centre right.

If you have any further thoughts or comments, you can always reply to this email or write to me at russell@transportlc.org.

19 Edward St, Adelaide, South Australia 5051

The Transport Leader Newsletter

Join 4000+ of the world’s best transport professionals, consultants, academics and advocates who use the weekly Transport Leader newsletter and blog to provide them with key insights into building better transport systems.

Read more from The Transport Leader Newsletter
What Do We Actually Mean by Seamless Transport?

Subscribe Welcome. In Today's Transport Leader: What Do We Actually Mean by Seamless Transport? Pricing the Curb: What the Evidence Says About Residential Parking Half the Cost, Half the Time: Coventry’s Very Light Rail Plus Quick Trips, Tool, Special Offer and Jobs Read online Policy What Do We Actually Mean by Seamless Transport? Seamlessness is a concept that has gained traction in transport circles in recent years, but what does it actually mean? This paper is a systematic literature...

How AI Could Really Transform Transport Outcomes

November 12th, 2026 Subscribe How AI Could Really Transform Transport Outcomes Key Takeaways AI will make transport policy, strategy, and planning faster, cheaper, and, for under-resourced agencies, higher quality, but these process gains alone won’t transform transport outcomes. Many transport strategies already say the right things; the real bottleneck is the political decisions that follow them. Public opinion and the car lobby keep pushing politicians towards bigger roads, and better...

​​​From Paris to Madrid: Lessons for Better High-Speed Rail

Subscribe Welcome. In Today's Transport Leader: From Paris to Madrid: Lessons for Better High-Speed Rail Urban Living Labs: Good Intentions, Limited Transformation Inside the UK’s New Transport Resilience Strategy Plus Quick Trips, Tool, Special Offer and Jobs Read online High-Speed Rail From Paris to Madrid: Lessons for Better High-Speed Rail What lessons can we learn from Spain and France's High-Speed Rail systems? This report from a study tour identified 8 lessons. Key Takeaways HSR works...